Sam Altman思想档案馆
Sam Altman 肖像

文献 文章 alt-100 机器译文 · 未审校

技术与财富不平等

Technology and wealth inequality

来源 Sam Altman (personal blog) · 英文原文出处

STATE2 中文可读 · 机器译文,未经人工审校 证据等级 A
中文为默认阅读视图

机器译文 本页中文为机器逐句翻译(qwen3.8-flash),未经人工审校,仅供阅读参考;引用与考据请以英文原文为准。 逐句机译与英文原文 1:1 存档(36 段);未经人工审校。

拜技术所赐,人们现在能创造的财富比以往任何时候都多,二十年后他们还能创造比今天更多的财富。尽管这会带来更多的总财富,但它会把财富集中到更少的人手中。这种差距大概从最广义意义上的技术诞生之初就一直在扩大。 Thanks to technology, people can create more wealth now than ever before, and in twenty years they’ll be able to create more wealth than they can today.  Even though this leads to more total wealth, it skews it toward fewer people. This disparity has probably been growing since the beginning of technology, in the broadest sense of the word.

技术让财富不平等恶化,是因为它给人们加了杠杆,把能力和工作量的差异复利放大。它还常常用机器取代人的工作。很久以前,能力和敬业程度的差异对财富的影响是线性的;现在则是指数级的。[1] 技术导致财富不平等加剧还有很多其他原因——例如,它让一次性触达海量受众变得容易得多,一个伟大的产品可以立即销往全世界,而不只是某一个地区。 Technology makes wealth inequality worse by giving people leverage and compounding differences in ability and amount of work.  It also often replaces human jobs with machines.  A long time ago, differences in ability and work ethic had a linear effect on wealth; now it’s exponential. [1] Technology leads to increasing wealth inequality for lots of other reasons, too—for example, it makes it much easier to reach large audiences all at once, and a great product can be sold immediately worldwide instead of in just one area.

如果不加干预,技术大概会导致一种难以为继的差距——所以我们大概需要某种程度的干预。技术也确实以增加总财富的方式让大多数人或多或少受益,但到了某个程度,差距大到让人感觉如此不公,那总财富的增加也就无所谓了。 Without intervention, technology will probably lead to an untenable disparity—so we probably need some amount of intervention.  Technology also increases the total wealth in a way that mostly benefits everyone, but at some point the disparity just feels so unfair it doesn’t matter.

而且至关重要的是,如果财富没有一个合理的基础保障水平,机会平等就无从谈起。 And critically, without a reasonable baseline of access to wealth, there can be no such thing as equality of opportunity.

今天美国的财富不平等已经很极端,而且还在扩大——每当有人朝谷歌班车的窗户扔砖头,我们就会热烈讨论一番。很多聪明人已经写过这个话题了,这里先用两张图快速展示这种倾斜的样子: Wealth inequality today in the United States is extreme and growing, and we talk about it a lot when someone throws a brick through the window of a Google bus.  Lots of smart people have already written about this, but here are two images to quickly show what the skew looks like:

[图片] [图片]

[0] [0]

正如下表所示,美国的财富不平等加剧已经持续了一段时间,而不只是最近几年。前 20% 与后 80% 之间的差距显而易见,前 1% 与后 99% 之间的差距尤其惊人。 As the following table shows, wealth inequality has been growing in America for some time, not just the last few years.  It’s noticeable between the top 20% and bottom 80%, and particularly noticeable between the top 1% and bottom 99%.

[图片] [图片]

这里还有一张图,展示前 1% 人群收入占比随时间的变化: And here is a graph that shows the income share of the top 1% over time:

[图片] [图片]

对于这种不断扩大的不平等,人们大概能说的最好的一句话是:它意味着我们正在取得技术进步——如果它没有发生,那才说明创新出了问题。但它成为问题的理由显而易见(而且一个社会中极端财富不平等的传统结局从来都不好看)。 The best thing one can probably say about this widening inequality is that it means we are making technological progress—if it were not happening, something would be going wrong with innovation. But it’s a problem for obvious reasons (and the traditional endings to extreme wealth inequality in a society are never good).

我们正在变成一个「有产者」与「无产者」的国家——繁荣的旧金山与破产的底特律。在旧金山,平均房价约 100 万美元。在底特律,平均房价还买不起一辆当地生产的雪佛兰迈锐宝。[2] 然而,我会认为旧金山一套 100 万美元的房子比底特律 20 套 5 万美元的房子是更好的投资。随着技术无情地向前推进,整类整类失去的工作永远不会回来,依赖这些已消失工作的城市处境艰难。[3] We are becoming a nation of haves and have-nots—of prosperous San Francisco vs. bankrupt Detroit.  In San Francisco, the average house costs around $1mm.  In Detroit, the average house costs less than a Chevy Malibu made there. [2] And yet, I’d view a $1mm house in San Francisco as a better investment than 20 $50k houses in Detroit.  As the relentless march of technology continues, whole classes of jobs lost are never coming back, and cities dependent on those lost jobs are in bad shape. [3]

这种不断扩大的财富鸿沟发生在所有层级——个人、公司和国家。要么它继续下去,要么创新停止。 This widening wealth divide is happening at all levels—people, companies, and countries.  And either it will keep going, or innovation will stop.

但它让人感觉非常不公平。人们似乎对相对经济地位比对绝对经济地位更敏感。所以即使今天做穷人比 500 年前做国王日子还好过,大多数人拿来比较的对象是今天最富的人,而不是过去最富的人。 But it feels really unfair. People seem to be more sensitive to relative economic status than absolute.  So even if people are much better off being poor today than king 500 years ago, most people compare themselves to the richest people today, and not the richest people from the past.

而且重要的是,它确实不公平。在美国试图靠最低工资生活是可怕的(见《福布斯》那篇关于麦当劳员工预算引发众怒的文章:http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2013/07/18/why-mcdonalds-employee-budget-has-everyone-up-in-arms/)。顺便说一句,那份预算还假设这位员工同时打着两份工。尽管那个人产出的价值更低,但他工作肯定比我辛苦。我们应该做更多来帮助这样的人。 And importantly, it really is unfair. Trying to live on minimum wage in the United States is atrocious (http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2013/07/18/why-mcdonalds-employee-budget-has-everyone-up-in-arms/ (http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2013/07/18/why-mcdonalds-employee-budget-has-everyone-up-in-arms/)).  That budget, incidentally, assumes that the worker is working two jobs.  Even though they’re outputting less value, that person is certainly working harder than I am.  We should do more to help people like this.

实际最低工资下降了,没有跟上实际平均工资,更是远远没有跟上前 1% 人群的收入。 Real minimum wage has declined, failing to track real averages wages and massively failing to track the wages of the top 1%.

[图片] [图片]

在一个想法和网络才是关键、制造成本趋于零的世界里,我们将不得不习惯越来越少的创造越来越多的财富这一事实。而我们需要为那些不创造大部分财富的人找到新的解决方案——反正许多最低工资岗位迟早会被创新消灭。 In a world where ideas and networks are what matter, and manufacturing costs trend towards zero, we are going to have to get comfortable with a smaller and smaller number of people creating more and more of the wealth.   And we need a new solution for the people not creating most of the wealth—many of the minimum wage jobs are going to get innovated away anyway.

没有显而易见或容易的解决方案,否则这一切早就解决了。我也没有什么了不起的答案,就抛砖引玉说一些想法。 There are no obvious/easy solutions, or this would all be resolved.  I don’t have any great answers, so I’ll just throw out some thoughts.

我们应该假设计算机将取代实际上所有的制造业,以及大多数任何形式的「重复性工作」。所以我们必须想清楚人类在哪些方面比计算机强。如果真正强大的 AI 出现,一切就难说了,但至少眼下,人类仍然垄断着「新想法」这个市场。在理想世界里,我们会在人类和计算机之间分工,让各自专注于自己擅长的事。 We should assume that computers will replace effectively all manufacturing, and also most “rote work” of any kind.  So we have to figure out what humans are better at than computers.  If really great AI comes along, all bets are off, but at least for now, humans still have the market cornered on new ideas.   In an ideal world, we’d divide labor among humans and computer so that we can both focus on what we’re good at.

有理由保持乐观。蒸汽机出现时,很多人失去了体力劳动的工作,但他们找到了其他事情做。工厂出现时,图景看起来糟糕得多。然而我们又一次找到了新的工作类型。这一次,我们或许会看到更多的程序员和创业公司。 There is reason to be optimistic.   When the steam engine came along, a lot of people lost their manual labor jobs.  But they found other things to do.  And when factories came along, the picture looked much worse.   And yet, again, we found new kinds of jobs.  This time around, we may see lots more programmers and startups.

更好的教育——在对的领域——大概是解决这个问题的最佳途径。我对现在许多教育创业公司持怀疑态度,但我确实相信这是一个可解的问题。快速改变我们教人们什么、怎么教,至关重要——如果一切都在变化,我们不能沿用同样的教育模式还指望它继续管用。如果大类别的工作被消灭,希望我们能教人们新的技能,鼓励他们去做新的事情。 Better education—in the right areas—is probably the best way to solve this.  I am skeptical of many current education startups, but I do believe this is a solvable problem.  A rapid change in what and how we teach people is critical—if everything is changing, we cannot keep the same model for education and expect it to continue to work. If large classes of jobs get eliminated, hopefully we can teach people new skills and encourage them to do new things.

教育不同于许多其他政府开支,它实际上是一种投资——我们应当能以 GDP 增长的形式获得它的投资回报(不过当然,回报周期很长)。 Education, unlike a lot of other government spending, is actually an investment—we ought to get an ROI on it in terms of increased GDP (but of course it takes a long time to pay back).

然而,如果我们无法为数十亿人找到新的工作类型,我们将面对一个新的有闲阶级。显而易见的结论是,政府将不得不直接给这些人钱,而关于「基本收入」(basic income)的讨论也越来越多——也就是说,任何想要的成年人都可以拿到比如说每年 1.5 万美元。 However, if we cannot find a new kind of work for billions of people, we’ll be faced with a new idle class.  The obvious conclusion is that the government will just have to give these people money, and there’s been increasing talk about a “basic income”—i.e, any adult who wanted it could have, say, $15,000 a year.

你可以把账算得大致说得通——如果给美国每个成年人发这笔钱,一年大约是 3.5 万亿美元,略高于我们 GDP 的 20%。不过,这会取代大量现有的福利开支,也许占 GDP 的 10%。而且我们大概会对收入超过某个门槛的人逐步停发,这会大幅削减总额。 You can run the numbers in a way that sort of makes sense—if we did this for every adult in the US, it’d be about $3.5 trillion a year, or a little more than 20% of our GDP.  However, we’d knock out a lot of existing entitlement spending, maybe 10% of GDP.  And we’d probably phase it out for people making over a certain threshold, which could cut it substantially.

这样做有好处——我们最终会更多地帮助真正贫困的人、更少地帮助中产阶级,而且大概能砍掉大量政府官僚机构。我们或许能在一夜之间终结贫困(尽管毫无疑问,任何这样的措施都会导致物价上涨)。这笔钱的大部分也很可能被花掉,对经济产生一定提振。我们可以要求每周为政府工作 10 小时,也可以不要求。这一策略的一大问题是,我认为它对缓解不平等感起不了多大作用。 There are benefits to this—we’d end up helping truly poor people more and middle class people less, and we’d presumably cut a ton of government bureaucracy.  We could perhaps end poverty overnight (although, no doubt, anything like this would cause prices to rise).  And likely most of this money would be spent, providing some boost to the economy.  We could require 10 hours a week of work for the government, or not.  A big problem with this strategy is that I don’t think it’ll do much to address the feeling of inequality.

许多人本能地厌恶「白给钱」的想法(尽管我认为要合理地拉平机会,某种程度的财富再分配是必需的),而且默认的担心当然是人们会无所事事、在网上浪费时间。但也许,如果每个人都知道自己有安全网,我们会得到更多的创业公司、更多的新研究、更多的小说。即使只有一小部分人有产出,在一个一些人创造的价值是其他人一万倍的世界里,那也没关系。我想表达的主要观点是:我们很可能不得不做一些新的、让人不舒服的事,而且我们应该对任何新想法保持开放。 Many people have a visceral dislike to the idea of giving away money (though I think some redistribution of wealth is required to reasonably equalize opportunity), and certainly the default worry is that people would just sit around and waste time on the Internet. But maybe, if everyone knew they had a safety net, we’d get more startups, or more new research, or more novels. Even if only a small percentage of people were productive, in a world where some people create 10,000x more value than others, that’d be ok.  The main point I’m trying to make is that we’re likely going to have to do something new and uncomfortable, and we should be open to any new ideas.

但这仍然没有触及根本问题——我相信大多数人想要成为有产出的人。而我认为,找到一种好得多的方式、把技术教给多得多的人,大概是实现这一点的最佳途径。 But this still doesn’t address the fundamental issue—I believe most people want to be productive.  And I think figuring out a much better way to teach a lot more people about technology is likely the best way to make that happen.

感谢 Nick Sivo 阅读本文草稿。 Thanks to Nick Sivo for reading a draft of this.

在 Twitter 上关注我:http://twitter.com/sama Follow me on Twitter here: http://twitter.com/sama

[0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPKKQnijnsM [0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPKKQnijnsM

[1] 造成财富不平等的其他重要因素还有很多——例如,有钱会让人更容易赚更多的钱——但技术是一个重要且常被忽视的因素。 [1] There are lots of other significant factors that cause wealth inequality—for example, having money makes it easier to make more money—but technology is an important and often-overlooked piece

[2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/20/home-cost_n_1690109.html [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/20/home-cost_n_1690109.html (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/20/home-cost_n_1690109.html)

[3] 我最近去了底特律,好奇地看了看那些可以花 1 万—2 万美元买到房子的社区。这里有几张照片:(略) [3] I was recently in Detroit and was curious to see some of the neighborhoods where you can buy houses for $10-20k.  Here are some pictures:

[图片] [图片]

出处与译稿

来源平台
Sam Altman (personal blog)
发表时间
2014 年 1 月 28 日
译稿来源
机器逐句翻译 · qwen3.8-flash
审校状态
未经人工审校(reviewed = 0)
译文存档
正式档案库 · translation 表
原文存档
正式档案库 · segment 表
收录状态
STATE2 · 中文暂不可用

中文译文为阅读默认视图;引用与考据请以英文原文为准。外部链接仅作为来源引用保留。

回到正文开头