作者:Sam Altman · 2021年3月16日 by Sam Altman · March 16, 2021 ¶
我在 OpenAI 的工作每天都在提醒我这场社会经济巨变的量级——它来得比多数人相信的更快。会思考、会学习的软件将承担越来越多如今由人完成的工作。更多的权力将从劳动转移到资本。如果公共政策不做相应的调整,大多数人最终的处境将不如今天。 My work at OpenAI reminds me every day about the magnitude of the socioeconomic change that is coming sooner than most people believe. Software that can think and learn will do more and more of the work that people now do. Even more power will shift from labor to capital. If public policy doesn’t adapt accordingly, most people will end up worse off than they are today. ¶
我们需要设计一个拥抱这一技术未来的体系,对构成那个世界大部分价值的资产——公司和土地——征税,从而公平地分配即将到来的财富中的一部分。这样做可以让未来的社会大大减少分裂,并让每个人都分享到它的收益。 We need to design a system that embraces this technological future and taxes the assets that will make up most of the value in that world–companies and land–in order to fairly distribute some of the coming wealth. Doing so can make the society of the future much less divisive and enable everyone to participate in its gains. ¶
未来五年内,会思考的计算机程序将能阅读法律文件、提供医疗建议。未来十年内,它们将从事流水线工作,甚至可能成为人们的陪伴。在那之后的几十年里,它们将几乎做所有事情,包括做出将拓展我们「万物」概念的新科学发现。 In the next five years, computer programs that can think will read legal documents and give medical advice. In the next decade, they will do assembly-line work and maybe even become companions. And in the decades after that, they will do almost everything, including making new scientific discoveries that will expand our concept of “everything.” ¶
这场技术革命不可阻挡。而这些智能机器本身会帮助我们制造更智能的机器,这种递归式创新循环将加快革命的步伐。随之而来的是三个关键后果: This technological revolution is unstoppable. And a recursive loop of innovation, as these smart machines themselves help us make smarter machines, will accelerate the revolution’s pace. Three crucial consequences follow: ¶
- 这场革命将创造惊人的财富。一旦足够强大的 AI 「加入劳动力市场」,许多种劳动的价格(它驱动着商品和服务的成本)将趋向于零。 - This revolution will create phenomenal wealth. The price of many kinds of labor (which drives the costs of goods and services) will fall toward zero once sufficiently powerful AI “joins the workforce.” ¶
- 世界的变化将如此迅速而剧烈,以至于需要同样剧烈的政策变革来分配这些财富,让更多人能够追求自己想要的生活。 - The world will change so rapidly and drastically that an equally drastic change in policy will be needed to distribute this wealth and enable more people to pursue the life they want. ¶
- 如果我们把这两件事都做对了,我们将能以前所未有的幅度提高人们的生活水平。 - If we get both of these right, we can improve the standard of living for people more than we ever have before. ¶
因为我们正处在这场构造性转变的起点,我们拥有转向未来的罕见机会。这个转向不能只是解决当下的社会和政治问题;它必须是为不远的未来那个截然不同的社会而设计的。不考虑这场迫在眉睫的变革的政策方案将会失败,正如农耕社会之前或封建社会的组织原则在今天必然失败一样。 Because we are at the beginning of this tectonic shift, we have a rare opportunity to pivot toward the future. That pivot can’t simply address current social and political problems; it must be designed for the radically different society of the near future. Policy plans that don’t account for this imminent transformation will fail for the same reason that the organizing principles of pre-agrarian or feudal societies would fail today. ¶
下面是对即将到来的事情的描述,以及一份如何驾驭这片新天地的方案。 What follows is a description of what’s coming and a plan for how to navigate this new landscape. ¶
## 第一部分 Part 1 ¶
### AI 革命 The AI Revolution ¶
把时间的尺度拉远来看,技术进步遵循一条指数曲线。比较一下 15 年前的世界(其实还没有智能手机)、150 年前(没有内燃机,没有家用电力)、1500 年前(没有工业机器)和 15000 年前(没有农业)。 On a zoomed-out time scale, technological progress follows an exponential curve. Compare how the world looked 15 years ago (no smartphones, really), 150 years ago (no combustion engine, no home electricity), 1,500 years ago (no industrial machines), and 15,000 years ago (no agriculture). ¶
即将到来的变革将围绕我们最了不起的能力展开:思考、创造、理解和推理的非凡能力。在三大技术革命——农业革命、工业革命和计算革命——之后,我们将迎来第四次:AI 革命。如果我们作为一个社会负责任地加以管理,这场革命将创造出足以让每个人各取所需的财富。 The coming change will center around the most impressive of our capabilities: the phenomenal ability to think, create, understand, and reason. To the three great technological revolutions–the agricultural, the industrial, and the computational–we will add a fourth: the AI revolution. This revolution will generate enough wealth for everyone to have what they need, if we as a society manage it responsibly. ¶
我们在未来 100 年取得的技术进步,将远远超过自最初学会用火和发明轮子以来的全部进步。我们已经造出了能够学习并做有用事情的 AI 系统。它们还很初级,但趋势线是清晰的。 The technological progress we make in the next 100 years will be far larger than all we’ve made since we first controlled fire and invented the wheel. We have already built AI systems that can learn and do useful things. They are still primitive, but the trendlines are clear. ¶
## 第二部分 Part 2 ¶
### 万物摩尔定律 Moore's Law for Everything ¶
笼统地说,过上好日子有两条路径:个人拥有更多钱(这让这个人更富有),或者价格下降(这让每个人都更富有)。财富就是购买力:用我们拥有的资源能换到多少东西。 Broadly speaking, there are two paths to affording a good life: an individual acquires more money (which makes that person wealthier), or prices fall (which makes everyone wealthier). Wealth is buying power: how much we can get with the resources we have. ¶
增加社会财富的最佳途径是降低商品的成本,从食品到电子游戏。技术将迅速推动许多品类成本的下降。以半导体和摩尔定律为例:几十年来,同样价格的芯片大约每两年性能翻一倍。 The best way to increase societal wealth is to decrease the cost of goods, from food to video games. Technology will rapidly drive that decline in many categories. Consider the example of semiconductors and Moore’s Law: for decades, chips became twice as powerful for the same price about every two years. ¶
过去几十年里,美国电视、电脑和娱乐的成本下降了。但其他成本大幅上升,最突出的是住房、医疗和高等教育。如果这些成本继续飙升,单靠财富再分配是行不通的。 In the last couple of decades, costs in the US for TVs, computers, and entertainment have dropped. But other costs have risen significantly, most notably those for housing, healthcare, and higher education. Redistribution of wealth alone won’t work if these costs continue to soar. ¶
AI 将降低商品和服务的成本,因为劳动是供应链上许多环节的主要成本。如果机器人能在你已经拥有的土地上、用现场开采和提炼的自然资源、以太阳能供电来建造房屋,那么建房成本就接近于租用机器人的成本。而如果这些机器人是由其他机器人制造的,租用它们的成本就会比由人制造时低得多。 AI will lower the cost of goods and services, because labor is the driving cost at many levels of the supply chain. If robots can build a house on land you already own from natural resources mined and refined onsite, using solar power, the cost of building that house is close to the cost to rent the robots. And if those robots are made by other robots, the cost to rent them will be much less than it was when humans made them. ¶
同样,我们可以想象比任何人类都更善于诊断健康问题的 AI 医生,以及能够精确诊断并解释学生哪里没听懂的 AI 教师。 Similarly, we can imagine AI doctors that can diagnose health problems better than any human, and AI teachers that can diagnose and explain exactly what a student doesn’t understand. ¶
「万物摩尔定律」应该成为这样一代人的集结口号:他们想要的东西自己负担不起。这听起来像乌托邦,但这是技术能够交付的东西(在某些领域已经交付了)。想象这样一个世界:几十年间,一切——住房、教育、食品、服装等等——每两年便宜一半。 “Moore’s Law for everything” should be the rallying cry of a generation whose members can’t afford what they want. It sounds utopian, but it’s something technology can deliver (and in some cases already has). Imagine a world where, for decades, everything–housing, education, food, clothing, etc.–became half as expensive every two years. ¶
我们会发现新的工作——每次技术革命之后我们都是如此——而且由于彼岸的丰裕,我们将拥有令人难以置信的自由,去创造性地定义这些工作是什么。 We will discover new jobs–we always do after a technological revolution–and because of the abundance on the other side, we will have incredible freedom to be creative about what they are. ¶
## 第三部分 Part 3 ¶
### 人人共享的资本主义 Capitalism for Everyone ¶
一个稳定的经济体系需要两个组成部分:增长与包容性。经济增长之所以重要,是因为大多数人希望自己的生活逐年改善。在一个零和世界里——没有增长或增长极少的世界——民主可能变得敌对,因为人们会试图通过投票把别人的钱变成自己的。随之而来的敌对会滋生不信任和两极分化。在一个高增长的世界里,这样的恶斗会少得多,因为人人都赢要容易得多。 A stable economic system requires two components: growth and inclusivity. Economic growth matters because most people want their lives to improve every year. In a zero-sum world, one with no or very little growth, democracy can become antagonistic as people seek to vote money away from each other. What follows from that antagonism is distrust and polarization. In a high-growth world the dogfights can be far fewer, because it’s much easier for everyone to win. ¶
经济包容性意味着每个人都有合理的机会获得过上自己想要的生活所需的资源。它之所以重要,是因为它公平、能造就稳定的社会、能为最多的人创造最大块的饼。附带的好处是,它还能带来更多增长。 Economic inclusivity means everyone having a reasonable opportunity to get the resources they need to live the life they want. Economic inclusivity matters because it’s fair, produces a stable society, and can create the largest slices of pie for the most people. As a side benefit, it produces more growth. ¶
资本主义是经济增长的强大引擎,因为它奖励人们对随时间产生价值的资产进行投资,这是一套创造和分配技术收益的有效激励体系。但资本主义进步的代价是不平等。 Capitalism is a powerful engine of economic growth because it rewards people for investing in assets that generate value over time, which is an effective incentive system for creating and distributing technological gains. But the price of progress in capitalism is inequality. ¶
一定程度的不平等是可以接受的——事实上它不可或缺,所有试图做到完全平等的体系都证明了这一点——但一个不能为每个人提供充分晋升机会均等的社会,是无法长久的。 Some inequality is ok–in fact, it’s critical, as shown by all systems that have tried to be perfectly equal–but a society that does not offer sufficient equality of opportunity for everyone to advance is not a society that will last. ¶
解决不平等的传统方式是对收入实行累进税。出于种种原因,这种方式效果并不理想。在未来,它的效果还会糟糕得多。人们虽然仍会有工作,但其中许多工作将不再是按我们今天理解的方式创造大量经济价值的工作。随着 AI 生产出世界上大部分的基本商品和服务,人们将被解放出来,把更多时间花在关心的人身上、照顾他人、欣赏艺术与自然,或致力于社会公益。 The traditional way to address inequality has been by progressively taxing income. For a variety of reasons, that hasn’t worked very well. It will work much, much worse in the future. While people will still have jobs, many of those jobs won’t be ones that create a lot of economic value in the way we think of value today. As AI produces most of the world’s basic goods and services, people will be freed up to spend more time with people they care about, care for people, appreciate art and nature, or work toward social good. ¶
因此,我们应把重点放在对资本而非劳动征税上,并且应利用这些税收作为机会,把所有权和财富直接分配给公民。换句话说,改进资本主义的最佳方式,是让每个人都能以股权所有者的身份直接从中受益。这不是一个新想法,但随着 AI 日益强大,它将变得前所未有地可行,因为可供分配的财富将多得多。财富的两大主导来源将是:1)公司,尤其是利用 AI 的公司;2)土地,它的供给是固定的。 We should therefore focus on taxing capital rather than labor, and we should use these taxes as an opportunity to directly distribute ownership and wealth to citizens. In other words, the best way to improve capitalism is to enable everyone to benefit from it directly as an equity owner. This is not a new idea, but it will be newly feasible as AI grows more powerful, because there will be dramatically more wealth to go around. The two dominant sources of wealth will be 1) companies, particularly ones that make use of AI, and 2) land, which has a fixed supply. ¶
落实这两项税收有很多方式,对于税收到手后怎么用也有很多想法。在足够长的时间尺度上,也许大多数其他税种都可以取消。下面这个设想,权当抛砖引玉。 There are many ways to implement these two taxes, and many thoughts about what to do with them. Over a long period of time, perhaps most other taxes could be eliminated. What follows is an idea in the spirit of a conversation starter. ¶
我们可以建立一个「美国股权基金」(American Equity Fund)。该基金的资金来源是:对市值超过某一门槛的公司,每年按其市值的 2.5% 征税,以转入基金的股份形式缴纳;以及对所有私人持有土地价值的 2.5% 征税,以美元缴纳。 We could do something called the American Equity Fund. The American Equity Fund would be capitalized by taxing companies above a certain valuation 2.5% of their market value each year, payable in shares transferred to the fund, and by taxing 2.5% of the value of all privately-held land, payable in dollars. ¶
所有年满 18 岁的公民每年都会收到一笔以美元和公司股票形式发放到其账户的分配。人们将被信任可以按自己的需要或意愿使用这笔钱——更好的教育、医疗、住房、创业,什么都行。随着更多人在竞争性市场中自主选择服务,政府资助行业不断上涨的成本将面临真实的压力。 All citizens over 18 would get an annual distribution, in dollars and company shares, into their accounts. People would be entrusted to use the money however they needed or wanted—for better education, healthcare, housing, starting a company, whatever. Rising costs in government-funded industries would face real pressure as more people chose their own services in a competitive marketplace. ¶
只要这个国家持续变得更好,每位公民每年从基金获得的钱就会更多(平均而言;经济周期仍会存在)。于是,每位公民将越来越多地享有经济自决带来的自由、权力、自主与机会。贫困将大幅减少,更多人将有机会过上自己想要的生活。 As long as the country keeps doing better, every citizen would get more money from the Fund every year (on average; there will still be economic cycles). Every citizen would therefore increasingly partake of the freedoms, powers, autonomies, and opportunities that come with economic self-determination. Poverty would be greatly reduced and many more people would have a shot at the life they want. ¶
以公司股份形式缴纳的税,会让公司、投资者和公民的激励对齐,而对利润征税做不到这一点——激励就是超能力,这是一个关键区别。公司利润可以被掩盖、递延或转移到海外,而且往往与股价脱节。但每个持有 Amazon 股份的人都希望股价上涨。当个人资产与国家命运同涨同落时,人们就在字面意义上与国家的兴旺利害相关。 A tax payable in company shares will align incentives between companies, investors, and citizens, whereas a tax on profits does not–incentives are superpowers, and this is a critical difference. Corporate profits can be disguised or deferred or offshored, and are often disconnected from share price. But everyone who owns a share in Amazon wants the share price to rise. As people’s individual assets rise in tandem with the country’s, they have a literal stake in seeing their country do well. ¶
美国政治经济学家 Henry George 在 19 世纪末提出了土地价值税的构想。这一概念得到经济学家的广泛支持。土地之所以升值,是因为社会围绕它所做的事情:在地块周围经营的公司的网络效应、使之可达的公共交通、以及令其宜居的附近餐馆、咖啡馆和自然条件。既然地主并没有做这些工作,那么这部分价值由成就了它的整个社会分享,才是公平的。 Henry George, an American political economist, proposed the idea of a land-value tax in the late 1800s. The concept is widely supported by economists. The value of land appreciates because of the work society does around it: the network effects of the companies operating around a piece of land, the public transportation that makes it accessible, and the nearby restaurants, coffeeshops, and access to nature that makes it desirable. Because the landowner didn’t do all that work, it’s fair for that value to be shared with the larger society that did. ¶
如果每个人都拥有美国价值创造的一份,每个人都会希望美国做得更好:对创新与国家成功的集体持股,将让我们的激励对齐。新的社会契约将是:人人有保底,无人设上限,以及一个共同信念——技术能够也必须带来社会财富的良性循环。(我们仍然需要政府的强有力领导,以确保追求股价上涨的愿望与保护环境、人权等目标保持平衡。) If everyone owns a slice of American value creation, everyone will want America to do better: collective equity in innovation and in the success of the country will align our incentives. The new social contract will be a floor for everyone in exchange for a ceiling for no one, and a shared belief that technology can and must deliver a virtuous circle of societal wealth. (We will continue to need strong leadership from our government to make sure that the desire for stock prices to go up remains balanced with protecting the environment, human rights, etc.) ¶
在一个人人都以所有者身份从资本主义中受益的世界里,集体的焦点将落在让世界「更好」而不是「没那么坏」上。这两种思路的差别比看上去更大,而当社会聚焦于前者时,表现会好得多。简言之,「更好」意味着把饼做得尽可能大,「没那么坏」意味着把饼分得尽可能公平。两者都能一次性提高人们的生活水平,但只有饼在变大时,增长才会持续。 In a world where everyone benefits from capitalism as an owner, the collective focus will be on making the world “more good” instead of “less bad.” These approaches are more different than they seem, and society does much better when it focuses on the former. Simply put, more good means optimizing for making the pie as large as possible, and less bad means dividing the pie up as fairly as possible. Both can increase people’s standard of living once, but continuous growth only happens when the pie grows. ¶
## 第四部分 Part 4 ¶
### 实施与排障 Implementation and Troubleshooting ¶
可用于充实美国股权基金的财富规模相当可观。仅美国公司的市值就约为 50 万亿美元。假设它像过去一个世纪的平均水平那样,在未来十年至少翻一倍。 The amount of wealth available to capitalize the American Equity Fund would be significant. There is about $50 trillion worth of value, as measured by market capitalization, in US companies alone. Assume that, as it has on average over the past century, this will at least double over the next decade. ¶
美国私人持有的土地(不含土地上的附着物)价值约 30 万亿美元。假设这部分价值在未来十年也大致翻一倍——这比历史速度略快,但随着世界真正开始理解 AI 将带来的转变,土地作为少数真正有限的资产之一,其价值理应更快上涨。 There is also about $30 trillion worth of privately-held land in the US (not counting improvements on top of the land). Assume that this value will roughly double, too, over the next decade–this is somewhat faster than the historical rate, but as the world really starts to understand the shifts AI will cause, the value of land, as one of the few truly finite assets, should increase at a faster rate. ¶
当然,如果我们提高持有土地的税负,土地相对于其他投资资产的价值会下降,这对社会是好事,因为它让一种基础性资源更可及,并鼓励投资而非投机。公司的价值短期内也会下降,尽管它们的长期表现仍会相当不错。 Of course, if we increase the tax burden on holding land, its value will diminish relative to other investment assets, which is a good thing for society because it makes a fundamental resource more accessible and encourages investment instead of speculation. The value of companies will diminish in the short-term, too, though they will continue to perform quite well over time. ¶
合理的假设是:这样的税会使土地和公司资产价值下跌 15%(而这只需要几年就能恢复!)。 It’s a reasonable assumption that such a tax causes a drop in value of land and corporate assets of 15% (which only will take a few years to recover!). ¶
在上述假设(现值、未来增长、新税导致的价值减损)之下,十年后美国 2.5 亿成年人每人每年将得到约 13,500 美元。如果 AI 加速了增长,这笔分红可能高得多;但即使没有,13,500 美元的购买力也会比今天大得多,因为技术将大幅降低商品和服务的成本。而且这种有效购买力将逐年大幅提升。 Under the above set of assumptions (current values, future growth, and the reduction in value from the new tax), a decade from now each of the 250 million adults in America would get about $13,500 every year. That dividend could be much higher if AI accelerates growth, but even if it’s not, $13,500 will have much greater purchasing power than it does now because technology will have greatly reduced the cost of goods and services. And that effective purchasing power will go up dramatically every year. ¶
对公司来说,最简单的缴税方式是每年发行占其价值 2.5% 的新股。显然,公司会有动机通过迁册海外来逃避美国股权基金的税,但一个简单的测试——按来自美国的收入占比判定——即可化解这一担忧。这个想法更大的问题在于:它会激励公司把价值返还股东,而不是把利润再投资于增长。 It would be easiest for companies to pay the tax each year by issuing new shares representing 2.5% of their value. There would obviously be an incentive for companies to escape the American Equity Fund tax by off-shoring themselves, but a simple test involving a percentage of revenue derived from America could address this concern. A larger problem with this idea is the incentive for companies to return value to shareholders instead of reinvesting it in growth. ¶
如果我们只对上市公司征税,公司也会有动机保持不上市。对于年收入超过 10 亿美元的私营公司,我们可以让它们的股权税负在若干(有限的)年内累积,直至其上市。如果长期不上市,我们可以让它们以现金结清。 If we tax only public companies, there would also be an incentive for companies to stay private. For private companies that have annual revenue in excess of $1 billion, we could let their tax in equity accrue for a certain (limited) number of years until they go public. If they remain private for a long time, we could let them settle the tax in cash. ¶
我们需要设计制度,防止人们不断投票给自己发更多钱。一项界定税率允许区间的宪法修正案将是有力的护栏。重要的是税负不能大到扼杀增长——例如,对公司的税必须远小于其平均增长率。 We’d need to design the system to prevent people from consistently voting themselves more money. A constitutional amendment delineating the allowable ranges of the tax would be a strong safeguard. It is important that the tax not be so large that it stifles growth–for example, the tax on companies must be much smaller than their average growth rate. ¶
我们还需要一套健全的体系来核算土地的实际价值。一种方式是建立一支强大的联邦评估师队伍。另一种是让地方政府像现在核定房产税那样做评估,并继续用相同的评估值收取地方税。但如果某一年某个辖区内一定比例的交易价格与地方政府对物业价值的估计相差过远,那么该辖区内所有其他物业都将被向上或向下重新评估。 We’d also need a robust system for quantifying the actual value of land. One way would be with a corps of powerful federal assessors. Another would be to let local governments do the assessing, as they now do to determine property taxes. They would continue to receive local taxes using the same assessed value. However, if a certain percentage of sales in a jurisdiction in any given year falls too far above or below the local government’s estimate of the property’s values, then all the other properties in their jurisdiction would be reassessed up or down. ¶
理论上最优的做法是只对土地价值征税,而不对地上附着物征税。实践中,这个价值可能太难评估,因此我们可能需要对土地与其附着物的合并价值征税(税率更低,因为合并价值更高)。 The theoretically optimal system would be to tax the value of the land only, and not the improvements built on top of it. In practice, this value may turn out to be too difficult to assess, so we may need to tax the value of the land and the improvements on it (at a lower rate, as the combined value would be higher). ¶
最后,我们不能允许人们以其未来的基金分配进行借贷、出售或以其他方式作抵押,否则就无法真正解决长期公平分配财富的问题。政府只需让此类交易不具法律强制执行力即可。 Finally, we couldn’t let people borrow against, sell, or otherwise pledge their future Fund distributions, or we won’t really solve the problem of fairly distributing wealth over time. The government can simply make such transactions unenforceable. ¶
## 第五部分 Part 5 ¶
### 转向新体系 Shifting to the New System ¶
美好的未来并不复杂:我们需要技术来创造更多财富,需要政策来公平地分配它。一切必需品都将变得便宜,每个人都会有足够的钱买得起它。由于这一体系将广受欢迎,及早拥抱它的政策制定者将获得回报:他们自己也会变得极受欢迎。 A great future isn’t complicated: we need technology to create more wealth, and policy to fairly distribute it. Everything necessary will be cheap, and everyone will have enough money to be able to afford it. As this system will be enormously popular, policymakers who embrace it early will be rewarded: they will themselves become enormously popular. ¶
在大萧条时期,Franklin Roosevelt 得以建立起五年前没人认为可能的庞大社会保障网。我们如今正处在类似的时刻。因此,一场既亲商又亲民的运动,将团结起异常广泛的选民群体。 In the Great Depression, Franklin Roosevelt was able to enact a huge social safety net that no one would have thought possible five years earlier. We are in a similar moment now. So a movement that is both pro-business and pro-people will unite a remarkably broad constituency. ¶
启动美国股权基金的一种政治上可行、也能减轻转型阵痛的方式,是通过立法让我们逐步过渡到 2.5% 的税率。只有当 GDP 从立法通过之时增长 50% 之后,全额 2.5% 的税率才完全生效。及早从小额分配开始,既有激励作用,也有助于让人们适应一个新的未来。实现 50% 的 GDP 增长听起来要很久(经济增长 50% 达到 2019 年水平用了 13 年)。但一旦 AI 开始到来,增长将极为迅速。假以时日,随着我们对这两类基础性资产征税,我们很可能还能削减许多其他税种。 A politically feasible way to launch the American Equity Fund, and one that would reduce the transitional shock, would be with legislation that transitions us gradually to the 2.5% rates. The full 2.5% rate would only take hold once GDP increases by 50% from the time the law is passed. Starting with small distributions soon will be both motivating and helpful in getting people comfortable with a new future. Achieving 50% GDP growth sounds like it would take a long time (it took 13 years for the economy to grow 50% to its 2019 level). But once AI starts to arrive, growth will be extremely rapid. Down the line, we will probably be able to reduce a lot of other taxes as we tax these two fundamental asset classes. ¶
即将到来的变化不可阻挡。如果我们拥抱它并为之规划,我们就能用它创造一个更公平、更幸福、更繁荣的社会。未来可以美好到几乎无法想象。 The changes coming are unstoppable. If we embrace them and plan for them, we can use them to create a much fairer, happier, and more prosperous society. The future can be almost unimaginably great. ¶
感谢 Steven Adler、Daniela Amodei、Adam Baybutt、Chris Beiser、Jack Clark、Ryan Cohen、Tyler Cowen、Matt Danzeisen、Steve Dowling、Tad Friend、Lachy Groom、Chris Hallacy、Reid Hoffman、Ingmar Kanitscheider、Oleg Klimov、Matt Knight、Aris Konstantinidis、Andrew Kortina、Matt Krisiloff、Scott Krisiloff、John Luttig、Erik Madsen、Preston McAfee、Luke Miles、Arvind Neelakantan、David Oates、Cullen O'Keefe、Alethea Power、Raul Puri、Ilya Sutskever、Luke Walsh、Caleb Watney 和 Wojchiech Zaremba 审阅本文草稿,并感谢 Gregory Koberger 负责设计。 Thanks to Steven Adler, Daniela Amodei, Adam Baybutt, Chris Beiser, Jack Clark, Ryan Cohen, Tyler Cowen, Matt Danzeisen, Steve Dowling, Tad Friend, Lachy Groom, Chris Hallacy, Reid Hoffman, Ingmar Kanitscheider, Oleg Klimov, Matt Knight, Aris Konstantinidis, Andrew Kortina, Matt Krisiloff, Scott Krisiloff, John Luttig, Erik Madsen, Preston McAfee, Luke Miles, Arvind Neelakantan, David Oates, Cullen O’Keefe, Alethea Power, Raul Puri, Ilya Sutskever, Luke Walsh, Caleb Watney, and Wojchiech Zaremba for reviewing drafts of this, and to Gregory Koberger for designing it. ¶