Sam Altman思想档案馆
Sam Altman 肖像

文献 文章 alt-074 机器译文 · 未审校

增长与政府

Growth and Government

来源 Sam Altman (personal blog) · 英文原文出处

STATE2 中文可读 · 机器译文,未经人工审校 证据等级 A
中文为默认阅读视图

机器译文 本页中文为机器逐句翻译(qwen3.8-flash),未经人工审校,仅供阅读参考;引用与考据请以英文原文为准。 逐句机译与英文原文 1:1 存档(32 段);未经人工审校。

TL;DR:没有经济增长,民主就无法运转,因为选民身处一个零和系统之中。 TL;DR Without economic growth, democracy doesn’t work because voters occupy a zero-sum system.

我听到的第一条创业智慧是「提高销售额能解决所有问题」。这其实是 Paul Graham 那句「增长至关重要」的另一种说法,而这句话之所以成立,有很多原因——比如在早期为高估值提供依据、从而融到大笔资金,吸引最优秀的人并用股权支付他们的报酬,提供一层允许犯一些错误的缓冲,以及缓和内部矛盾。 The first piece of startup wisdom I heard was “increasing your sales will fix all problems”.   This turns out to be another way of phrasing Paul Graham’s point that growth is critical, which is true for all sorts of reasons—for example, justifying high valuations to raise large amounts of capital in the early days, attracting the best people and paying them with equity, providing a buffer to allow for some mistakes, and smoothing over internal tensions.

我相信,增长不仅对创业公司至关重要,对大多数系统都是如此。要么你在增长,要么你在慢慢死去。完美的均衡状态是罕见的。 I believe that growth is not only critical for startups, but for most systems.   Either you’re growing, or you’re slowly dying.  Perfect equilibrium is rare.

一个似乎正处于死亡初期挣扎中的系统,就是美国政府。政治上充满怨毒的对立,而想到 2012 年总统大选时奥巴马和罗姆尼说的其实大同小异,这种对立就格外令人费解。功能失调的程度很高——「自动减支」(sequester)本来被设计得如此难以接受、以至人们认为它永远不会真正生效,结果上周五它却真的(而且很可能是暂时地)发生了,因为两党无法就替代方案达成一致。大家在许多无关紧要的问题上争吵不休——吵得足够多,多到足以让我们忽略一个事实:在真正重大的问题上,没有人有新想法。我们有着数万亿美元的赤字,却没有任何削减赤字的计划,而媒体只盯着那些边角的杂耍表演。 One system that seems to be in early death throes is the United States government.  There’s a lot of political rancor, which is particularly puzzling when one considers that in the 2012 presidential election, Obama and Romney said roughly the same thing.  Dysfunction is high—the sequester, which was supposed to be so unpalatable it would never take effect, actually (and likely temporarily) happened last Friday because the parties couldn’t agree on an alternative. There’s a lot of arguing over insignificant issues—enough, in fact, to distract us from the fact that no one has new ideas on the big issues.  We have trillion dollar deficits and no plan to reduce them, and yet the media focus on the sideshows.

衡量政府功能失调的一个好指标,就是无法通过预算——其结果要么是政府停摆,要么是「延续性决议」(continuing resolution),即允许各机构按照上一期预算继续运转一段理论上很短的时间,直到我们能就新预算达成一致。通过预算是国会和总统最基本的职责。 A good metric for government dysfunction is inability to pass a budget, either leading to a government shutdown or a continuing resolution, which lets agencies continue to operate on the previous budget, for a theoretically short time period until we can agree on a new one.  Passing a budget is a fundamental job of Congress and the President.

据我观察,美国政府曾连续约 200 年没有发生过任何停摆。1976 年我们停摆了一次,随后在七八十年代又停摆了若干次,九十年代还有 3 次,其中一次持续了 21 天。停摆后来不再流行了,如今我们就靠延续性决议运转,而且数量很多——比如仅 2001 财年预算就有 21 项延续性决议。停摆和延续性决议背后的真正问题是同一个:无法就联邦预算达成一致。 As far as I can tell, the US government managed to make it about 200 years without any shutdowns.  We had one in 1976, and then a bunch more in the 70s and 80s, plus 3 in the 90s, including one that lasted 21 days.  Shutdowns have fallen out of fashion, and now we just operate with continuing resolutions, and lots of them—for example, 21 for the 2001 budget alone.  The real issue with shutdowns and continuing resolutions is the same—inability to agree on a federal budget.

每隔几个月,都会有一阵关于某种「大交易」(grand bargain)的简短讨论,但结局总是拖延——连拖延本身都被拖延了!人人都觉得自己吃了亏,几乎没有人认为政府干得出色。我们在任何事情上都无法达成一致,而任何提出激进不同方案的人都选不上。 Every few months, there’s brief discussion of some sort of grand bargain, but it always ends in deferral—even the deferrals get deferred!  Everyone feels screwed, and almost no one feels like the government is doing a great job.   We can’t agree on anything, and anyone that proposes doing something radically different doesn’t get elected.

但民主制度(我这里用「民主」来涵盖共和制以及其他人民对领导人选拥有实质性直接发言权的政府形式)在美国曾经长期有效——我们能够取得真正的进步、通过预算、成为世界超级大国、作为一个国家不断演进。一定是有什么东西变了。 But democracy (I’m using democracy to include republics and other forms of government where the people get an effectively direct say in who the leaders are) worked in the US for a long time—we were able to make real progress, pass budgets, be the world superpower, evolve as a country, etc.  Something has changed.

美国在很长时期里都得天独厚地拥有经济增长,起初靠的是自然资源和可供扩张的广袤土地,后来靠的是一段人类历史上罕有其匹的技术进步时期——这段时期大约持续到我们意识到核弹究竟有多危险、并开始害怕新技术为止。但 frontier(边疆扩张)时代早已结束,虽然计算机和互联网领域的技术创新仍在以惊人速度推进,但大多数其他行业的技术创新似乎已经放缓。 The US has been blessed with economic growth for a very long time, first due to natural resources and massive amounts of land in which to expand, and then due to a period of technological progress rarely matched in human history that lasted approximately until we realized just how dangerous nuclear bombs really were and got scared of new technology.  But the frontier is long over, and although technological innovation has continued at a blistering rate for computers and the Internet, it seems to have slowed down in most other industries.

增长可能正是「美国例外论」的根源——每个十年情况都持续变好,很大程度上就是因为我们在增长。其他国家的人想来这里生活,我们在技术创新上领先世界,社会流动性高,因为每个人都在变得更富,而且我们有资源去介入世界各地的事务。这一点至今至少还部分成立。 Growth may be the root cause of American exceptionalism—things consistently got better every decade largely because we were growing.  People from other countries wanted to live here, we led the world in technological innovation, social mobility was high because everyone was getting richer, and we had the resources to get involved around the world.  This is still at least partially true.

但增长已经放缓了不少。这是一张美国从 1950 年至今的实际 GDP 增长率图表,附有趋势线。趋势线从略低于 5% 降到略低于 2%。这个降幅比表面看起来严重得多,因为它是按指数复利的。 But growth has slowed quite a bit.  Here is a graph of real GDP percentage growth in the United States from 1950 until now, with a trendline.  The trendline goes from just under 5% to just under 2%.  This is a much more significant drop than it appears, because it compounds exponentially.

[图片] [图片]

关于现状,有一个令人震惊的数据点:以 35 岁以下者为户主的家庭,其实际净资产中位数从 1984 年到 2009 年下降了 68%,只剩 3,662 美元;而以 65 岁以上者为户主的家庭则增长了 42%,达到 170,494 美元(主要得益于房产价值的上涨)。这种悬殊差距是缺乏真实增长的有力证据(同时也是一种非常不稳定的局面——年长一代以年轻一代受损为代价获益)。 A shocking data point about how things are going is that the median real net worth for households headed by someone under 35 dropped 68% from 1984 to 2009, to $3,662.  For those over 65, it increased 42% to $170,494 (largely due to a gain in property values).  This disparity is good evidence of a lack of real growth (and also a very unstable situation where an older generation benefits at the expense of a younger).

这里还有两张图,第一张显示美国失业率(真实数字可能更糟,因为一些人退出了劳动力市场),第二张显示美国利率,两者都支持「增长正在放缓」的判断: Here are two more graphs, the first showing the US unemployment rate (the real numbers are perhaps worse, as people drop out of the work force) and the second showing the US interest rate, both of which make a case for slowing growth:

[图片] [图片]

话虽如此,从绝对意义上说,我还是宁愿生活在今日的世界而不是 1950 年——我很难想象生活在一个没有互联网的世界里。然而,就像人能感受到加速度却感受不到速度一样,人们似乎对每年的改善速率比对生活质量的绝对水平更敏感。所以,尽管在一个绝对更好的世界里人们理应更幸福,却没有人愿意在「享乐跑步机」上原地踏步。 All of that said, in absolute sense I’d much rather live in the world of today than 1950—it’s tough for me to imagine living in a world without the Internet. However, in the same way that one can feel acceleration but not velocity, people seem more sensitive to the annual rate of improvement than the absolute quality of life.  So even though people should be happier in an absolutely better world, no one wants to stand still on the hedonic treadmill.

我们大多数人都希望生活一年比一年好——享乐跑步机在这方面很是折磨人。在民主制度下,理论上我们投票支持那些我们相信自己最能改善生活的选项。在有经济增长的系统里,所有人的境遇都可以改善。在没有增长、甚至只有极少增长的系统里,情况就不是这样了——如果我的境遇改善,就必须以你的境遇恶化为代价。没有增长时,我们投票反对别人利益的成分,不亚于投票争取自己利益。这样的结局是争吵不休、人人觉得自己吃了亏、社会分裂成派系、人人失去动力。民主在零和世界里运转不良。威权政治体制大概同样在有增长时运转得更好,只不过缺乏增长的影响在这样的体制里可能不那么明显——直到革命爆发的那一刻。 Most of us want our lives to get better every year—the hedonic treadmill is a pain that way.  In a democracy, we theoretically vote for what we believe will improve our lives the most.  In a system with economic growth, things can improve for everyone.  In a system without growth, or even one with very little growth, that’s not the case—if things improve for me, it has to come at the expense of things getting worse for you.  Without growth, we’re voting against someone else’s interest as much as we’re voting for our own.  This ends with lots of fighting and everyone feeling screwed, broken into factions, and unmotivated.  Democracy does not work well in a zero-sum world. Autocratic political systems probably work better with growth too, but the effect of a lack of growth is likely less pronounced right up until the revolution.

所以我们需要把增长找回来,除非我们想眼看着这场伟大实验走向终结。我们的政客似乎对如何做到这一点没有任何好主意。嘴上说「我相信美国」,然后指望「反复高声断言就能自证成真」,这不叫战略。 So we need to get growth back, unless we want to see this grand experiment end.  Our politicians don’t seem to have any good ideas about how to do this.  Saying “I believe in America” and hoping that proof by vigorous assertion starts working is not a strategy.

我相信民主只在非零和世界里才行得通。我们正在失去一些永远无法挽回的工作岗位,我们正在借钱并把钱花在除真正投资之外的任何东西上,感觉就像我们在管理一场缓慢的衰退。没有增长,我们将滑向一种特殊版本的马尔萨斯式反乌托邦:垃圾食品有的是,其他什么都不够。 I believe democracy only works in a non-zero-sum world.  We are losing jobs that we will never get back, we are borrowing money and spending it on anything but real investment, and it feels like we are managing a slow decline.  Without growth, we will head towards a special case of Malthusian dystopia where we have plenty of junk food but not enough of anything else.

增长才是我们应该聚焦的东西。增长是件好事——它让我们能够维持赤字,它意味着国家不是零和的,它让我们能够投资于创新和基础设施的持续改进,它为一点管理失误提供缓冲,而且它意味着明天会比今天更好。与人们可能预期的相反,增长带来的是长期稳定。 Growth is what we should be focusing on.  Growth is great—it lets us run deficits, it means the country is not zero-sum, it lets us invest in innovation and continual improvement in infrastructure, it provides a buffer for a little mismanagement, and it means tomorrow will be better than today.  Contrary to what one might expect, growth provides long-term stability.

我们必须回到真正的增长——那种用更少做更多的增长。靠借钱来换取「一块钱里挤出九十分的增长」不算数,尽管这种做法可能撑得了一时。我们必须想办法用技术创新去解决真正的问题——更便宜、更清洁的能源,更好的医疗(医疗支出占 GDP 的比例 2008 年为 15.2%,2011 年为 18.2%),更好的交通、食品生产和国防。GDP 增长可能是解决我们国家债务和福利 entitlement 问题的唯一途径,而真实的增长总比通胀式的增长好。 We must return to real growth, growth where we do more with less. Borrowing money to get ninety growth cents on the dollar does not count, although that may work for a while.  We have to figure out how to fix the real problems with technological innovation—cheaper and cleaner energy, better healthcare (15.2% of GDP in 2008 and 18.2% of GDP in 2011), better transportation, food production, and defense.  GDP growth is probably the only way to fix our national debt and entitlement problems, and it’d be better to have real growth than inflationary growth.

如何最好地驱动经济增长是个难题。说「我们应该投资科学技术」很容易,虽然这大概是对的,但说来容易做来难。政府在挑选投资赢家方面历来很差,但我们的领导人或许可以帮助扭转那种从崇尚科学滑向反科学的文化转变。我们当前的文化已经变得反科学;对转基因食品和机器人之类事物的恐惧,显然挡在增长的路上。 How to best drive economic growth is a difficult question.  It’s easy to say we should just invest in science and technology, and although that’s probably right it’s easier said than done. The government is historically bad at picking winners to invest in, but our leaders can perhaps help reverse the cultural shift from pro-science to anti-science.  Our current culture has shifted to be anti-science; the fear of things like genetically modified food and robots is obviously in the way of growth.

我们应该努力让科学技术领域的工作比金融领域的工作更有吸引力(顺带一提,当最聪明的年轻人开始涌入金融业时,这对增长来说应该是一个大大的红色警报,因为他们其实并没有创造更多财富,只是在重新分配财富)。创业公司可能是实现这一点的最佳途径——创业公司让开发新技术的人自己富起来,而不只是让 GE 稍微更富一点。所以我们应该想尽一切办法鼓励创业公司。 We should strive to make jobs in science and technology more appealing than jobs in finance (incidentally, it should be a big red flag for growth when the brightest young people start going into finance, since they aren’t actually creating any more wealth, just redistributing it).  Startups are probably the best way to do this—startups let people that develop a new technology get rich, instead of just making GE slightly richer.  So we should encourage startups in whatever way we can.

另一个问题是我们国家预算的结构。用创业公司的行话说,我们有着很高的「烧钱率」(burn rate),而且其中大部分不能算作「投资」,而是「开销」。把钱花在基础设施改善或新技术这类未来可能带来更多收入的事情上,有助于增长;把钱花在所谓的 entitlement 福利项目和部分军费上,则无助于增长。当然,医疗和国防都很重要,我们必须要有——这是一场艰难的平衡。在某些情况下,私营部门的竞争性质可能提供一条更好的路径。迟早有一天,我们要就国家预算进行一场难看的对话——我们可以把它拖很久,但不可能永远拖下去。政府在确实需要花钱的时候,应该以投资为目标。思考「什么将驱动增长」,是思考资源最佳用途的一个有用框架。 Another issue is the structure of our national budget.  We have, in startup parlance, a high burn, and most of it can’t be considered ‘investment’ but is instead ‘expense’.  Spending money on things like infrastructure improvement or new technology that are likely to generate more money in the future helps growth; spending money on the so-called entitlement programs, and parts of the military, does not.  Of course medical care and defense are important, and we have to have them—this is a tough balancing act.  In some cases, the competitive nature of the private sector may provide a better path. Sooner or later, we are going to have an ugly conversation about our national budget—we can delay it for a long time but not forever.  The government, when it needs to spend money at all, should aim to invest. Considering what will drive growth is a useful framework for thinking about the best use of resources.

我们不应该害怕创新或全球化。机器人将在许多工厂里取代人类工人;那些仍然需要人类劳动的工作岗位,将继续转移到成本最低的地方。但这没关系,而且这类工作本来也不是将为我们创造经济增长的东西。我们应该努力成为思想和技术的净出口国。例如,美国今天制造着世界上最好的软件。如果这一点不复存在,对我们将是灾难性的。我们还应该设计最好的超音速喷气发动机、最好的核电站和最好的农业技术。 We should not fear innovation or globalization.  Robots are going to replace human workers in lots of factories; jobs that do require human labor are going to continue to move to the lowest-cost place.  But that’s ok, and these sorts of jobs are not what will generate economic growth for us anyway.  We should strive to be a net exporter of ideas and technologies.  For example, the US makes the best software in the world today. It’d be disastrous for us if that stopped happening.  We should also design the best supersonic jet engines, the best nuclear power plants, and the best agricultural technology.

我们应该明白,作为技术和「思想经济」的结果,贫富差距很可能在目前已经显得很高的水平上继续扩大。这件事有好的一面也有坏的一面,但我们要小心不要用立法去对抗它,因为那会伤害增长。技术会放大先天能力的差异;创业公司则提供了一个据此获得报酬的框架。但 GDP 增长理应改善每个人的生活质量,而没有增长则会降低除极富者之外所有人的生活质量。为真正贫困的人提供安全网是好事,而且在一个分化如此剧烈的世界里,它可能变得更加必要。每个人的生活质量都应该改善;更大的问题很可能在于,人们对相对公平极其敏感。 We should understand that as a consequence of technology and an economy of ideas, the gap between the rich and the poor will likely increase from its already high-seeming levels.  There is good and bad to this, but we should be careful not to legislate against it, which will hurt growth.   Technology magnifies differences in innate ability; startups provide a framework to get compensated for it.  But GDP growth ought to improve the quality of life for everyone, and no growth will reduce quality of life for everyone except the very rich.  A safety net for legitimately poor people is a good thing, and probably becomes more necessary in a world with this sort of divergence.  Quality of life should improve for everyone; the bigger issue will likely be that people are very sensitive to relative fairness.

促进增长的税收和法律改革是好主意。由于烧钱率高,我们不得不维持高税收。但其他国家没有这种结构性难题,所以有些国家的税率比我们低。这使得它们成为创办企业或居住的好地方。通过降低我们的烧钱率,我们就能降低税收。这件事上我们不必走极端——还有很多其他因素使美国成为创办新公司极具吸引力的地方。但降税肯定会有帮助。而且税收政策应该奖励那些驱动增长的活动。 Pro-growth tax and legal changes are a good idea.  As a consequence of a high burn rate, we have to have high taxes. But other countries don’t have this structural challenge, and so some other countries have lower tax rates than we do.  That makes them an appealing place to start a business or live.  By reducing our burn rate, we can reduce taxes. We don’t need to go crazy here—there are a lot of other factors that make the US a very attractive place to start a new company.  But it would certainly help.  And tax policy should reward activity that drives growth.

还有一些容易实现的法律改革可以促进增长。面向创业者和熟练技术工人的移民政策是显而易见的一项;我们应该希望最优秀的人在这里创造价值,而不是在世界上的其他地方。侵权法改革(tort reform)是另一项——法律保护当然重要,但它已经荒唐到抑制创新的程度。 There are some easy legal changes we can make to increase growth. Immigration for entrepreneurs and skilled technology workers is an obvious one; we should want the best people creating value here, not elsewhere in the world.  Tort reform is another—legal protection is of course important, but it’s gotten so silly that it discourages innovation.

我们还有很多能做的事。其中大多数都不容易,但增长就是那个关键问题。 There is a lot more we can do.  Most of it is difficult, but growth it is the critical issue.

作为结语:Airbnb 的创始人们过去会画一张他们想要达到的前瞻性增长曲线图。那是他们的头号优先事项;他们把它贴在书桌上、冰箱上,还有浴室的镜子上。「你度量什么,就会构建什么」(You build what you measure),而他们度量并构建的正是增长。这策略对他们似乎相当奏效。 As a closing thought, the Airbnb founders used to draw a forward-looking growth graph that they wanted to hit.  It was their number one priority; they put it up on their desks, on their refrigerator, and on the mirror in their bathroom.  You build what you measure, and they built growth.  That seemed to work pretty well for them.

如果换成美国政府,这就没那么容易了。但大概也并非不可能,而且它至少能给我们指出正确的方向。 It’s not as easy if you’re the US government.  But probably not impossible, either, and it would at least point us in the right direction.

感谢 Paul Graham、Nick Sivo 和 Peter Thiel 贡献了催生这篇博客文章的想法。 Thanks to Paul Graham, Nick Sivo, and Peter Thiel for contributing ideas that led to this blog post.

出处与译稿

来源平台
Sam Altman (personal blog)
发表时间
2013 年 3 月 5 日
译稿来源
机器逐句翻译 · qwen3.8-flash
审校状态
未经人工审校(reviewed = 0)
译文存档
正式档案库 · translation 表
原文存档
正式档案库 · segment 表
收录状态
STATE2 · 中文暂不可用

中文译文为阅读默认视图;引用与考据请以英文原文为准。外部链接仅作为来源引用保留。

回到正文开头